| 2021-22 | |
| Kyle Patton 'C' | Buffalo State |
| Harrison Dumas | Nazareth College |
| Adam Beauvais "A" | Brockport University |
| Tony Andrews | Alvernia University |
| Chris Blango | Buffalo State |
| Graham Burke | Hobart College |
| Joseph Henson | Ferris State (D1) |
| Connor MacDonell | Stevenson University |
| Vincent Nicosia "A" | UMass Dartmouth |
| Sebastian Rominiecki | Rivier University |
| Avery Arnold | Rivier University |
| Kaila Booth | Neumann University |
| Charlotte Labre | Neumann University |
| Sydney Babin | Wilkes University |
| Morgan Daly | Anna Maria College |
| 2020-21 | |
| Emma Besa | Kings College |
| Ryan Clear | Southern New Hampshire |
| Jake Frankenfield | Arcadia University |
| Jakub Kubik | Worcester State |
| Scott MeGraw "A" | Alvernia University |
| Brett Turner | Rivier University |
| Ryan Houle "C" | Southern New Hampshire |
| 2019-20 | |
| Jacob Berg "C" | Trine University |
| Soren Bredeson "A" | Morrisville State |
| Ryan Candia "A" | Westfield State University |
| Cam Lindsay | Framingham State University |
| Alex McBey | Stevenson University |
| Thomas McLarnon | Assumption College |
| *Avery Smith | St. Mary's University |
| Dan Mundy | University of Alabama |
| 2018-19 | |
| *Alex Peterson | Holy Cross (D1) |
| *Brett Abdelnour | Army West Point (D1) |
| Rece Bergeman | Fitchburg State University |
| Brendahn Brawley | Plymouth State University |
| Nick Daluisio "C" | UMass Boston |
| Nate Dunning | Neumann University |
| Austin Master "A" | Stevenson University |
| Zikmund Mroz "C" | Lebanon Valley College |
| Kyle Scott | Lebanon Valley College |
| Matt Shipko | Gustavus Adolphus |
| Cade Street "A" | Morrisville State |
| Bryce Witman | SUNY Fredonia |
| *Joseph Giacobbo | Utica College |
| *Brendan Coughlin | Lake Forest College |
| Nick Cramer | Albertus Magnus College |
| 2017-18 | |
| Nick Magill-Diaz | Trine University |
| Eric Higgins | Bryn Athyn College |
| Rick Walsh "A" | Framingham State University |
| Trevor Lewandoski "C" | Framingham State University |
| Joey Savel "C" | Utica College |
| Alex Ochterbeck "A" | Curry College |
| Trevor Micucci* | SUNY Buffalo State |
| Cameron Bartkoski* | Utica College |
| Ryan Galvin | Wilkes University |
| Trevor Coykendall* | Adrian College |
| Cale Coor | Southern Hampshire University |
| 2016-17 | |
| Peter Hatton "C" | Tufts University |
| Sam Kany | Trinity College |
| Jamie Bucell | Utica College |
| Chris Best "C" | Stevenson University |
| Christian Karbler | Trine University |
| Bobby Nate Rogers | Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| Evan Heldt "A" | UMass-Boston |
| Oliver Arnberg | Nichols College |
| Tyler Pietrowski* | Utica College |
| 2015-16 | |
| Austin Kelly "C" | University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point |
| Bruce Stachitas | Stevenson University |
| Braden Mitchell | University of Wisconsin- Eau Claire |
| Adem Arifi | Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| JC Moritz | Neumann University |
| Tim Higginbotham | Stevenson University |
| 2014-15 | |
| Jacob Paluch | Nazareth College |
| Cameron Berry "A" | SUNY-Oswego |
| Garrett Gallagher | UMass-Boston |
| Drew Gannon | UMass-Boston |
| Zach Felser "C" | Suny-Cortland |
| Gabe Chuckran "C" | UMass-Boston |
| Blake Delisle | Trinity College |
| Hector Majul | Curry College |
| Steve Mallory | Amherst College |
| John Nugent | Lake Forest College |
| Greg Procopio | Lawrence University |
| Nick Skerlick | Lebanon Valley |
| Cody Slocum | Worcester State |
| 2013-2014 | |
| Matt Day | University of New England |
| Stephen Gielarowski "C" | St. Mary's University |
| Carter Lukenda | St. Olaf |
| Jude Warner "C" | St. Mary's University |
| Cole Pierce | St. Mary's University |
| Chase Rigsby "A" | Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| *Mike Davis | Neumann University |
| 2012-2013 | |
| Sam Manzi | Williams College |
| Brian Oseija | Becker College |
| *Anthony Pino | Neumann University |
| *John Rey | Robert Morris University |
| *Doug Rose | Sacred Heart University |
| 2011-12 | |
| Ben Bauer | Curry College |
| John Carroll | Becker College |
| David Chiokadaze | Salve Regina |
| Matt Conway | Nazareth CollegeState |
| Mason Riley | Worcester State |
| Taylor Swarter | Castleton State |
| * (Alumni Commitment) |