| 2017-18 |
|
| Nick Magill-Diaz |
Trine University |
| Eric Higgins |
Bryn Athyn College |
| Rick Walsh "A" |
Framingham State University |
| Trevor Lewandoski "C" |
Framingham State University |
| Joey Savel "C" |
Utica College |
| Alex Ochterbeck "A" |
Curry College |
| Trevor Micucci* |
SUNY Buffalo State |
| Cameron Bartkoski* |
Utica College |
| Ryan Galvin |
Wilkes University |
| Trevor Coykendall* |
Adrian College |
| Cale Coor |
Southern Hampshire University |
| 2016-17 |
|
| Peter Hatton "C" |
Tufts University |
| Sam Kany |
Trinity College |
| Jamie Bucell |
Utica College |
| Chris Best "C" |
Stevenson University |
| Christian Karbler |
Trine University |
| Bobby Nate Rogers |
Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| Evan Heldt "A" |
UMass-Boston |
| Oliver Arnberg |
Nichols College |
| Tyler Pietrowski* |
Utica College |
| 2015-16 |
|
| Austin Kelly "C" |
University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point |
| Bruce Stachitas |
Stevenson University |
| Braden Mitchell |
University of Wisconsin- Eau Claire |
| Adem Arifi |
Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| JC Moritz |
Neumann University |
| Tim Higginbotham |
Stevenson University |
| 2014-15 |
|
| Jacob Paluch |
Nazareth College |
| Cameron Berry "A" |
SUNY-Oswego |
| Garrett Gallagher |
UMass-Boston |
| Drew Gannon |
UMass-Boston |
| Zach Felser "C" |
Suny-Cortland |
| Gabe Chuckran "C" |
UMass-Boston |
| Blake Delisle |
Trinity College |
| Hector Majul |
Curry College |
| Steve Mallory |
Amherst College |
| John Nugent |
Lake Forest College |
| Greg Procopio |
Lawrence University |
| Nick Skerlick |
Lebanon Valley |
| Cody Slocum |
Worcester State |
| 2013-2014 |
|
| Matt Day |
University of New England |
| Stephen Gielarowski "C" |
St. Mary's University |
| Carter Lukenda |
St. Olaf |
| Jude Warner "C" |
St. Mary's University |
| Cole Pierce |
St. Mary's University |
| Chase Rigsby "A" |
Milwaukee School of Engineering |
| *Mike Davis |
Neumann University |
| 2012-2013 |
|
| Sam Manzi |
Williams College |
| Brian Oseija |
Becker College |
| *Anthony Pino |
Neumann University |
| *John Rey |
Robert Morris University |
| *Doug Rose |
Sacred Heart University |
| 2011-12 |
|
| Ben Bauer |
Curry College |
| John Carroll |
Becker College |
| David Chiokadaze |
Salve Regina |
| Matt Conway |
Nazareth College |
| Mason Riley |
Worcester State |
| Taylor Swarter |
Castleton State |
